• 059
        • Faux Amis

        Abstract
        Irénée Scalbert analyses the position of the critic, elaborating the difficult relationship between the critic and the architect, against the background of the critical tradition in Great Britain. In the UK the position of the critic was unique, especially due to the works of critics like Reyner Banham, Colin Rowe in the 1960s and 1970s. Architecture criticism was understood as a form of intellectualism, sometimes opposing the practice of architecture, sometimes drawing a larger framework for practicing architects. The end of modernism, however, did not open the way for another approach in architecture, but for any other approach. This also has influenced criticism. According to Scalbert architecture criticism turned into a form of art criticism, emphasising complexity, uniqueness and craft. This perspective on differences has recently turned into the new object of criticism, as is the urgent and remaining issue of green architecture. But as Scalbert states in his essay: critics can only question these issues – answers have to be found in the practice of architecture.
          1. 059
          1. 060
          2. 061
          1. 062
          2. 063
          1. 064
        Citation
        Scalbert, I. (2010). Faux Amis. Constructing Criticism, OASE, (81), 59–64. Retrieved from https://www.oasejournal.nl/en/Issues/81/FauxAmis

        Download PDF (28.3 KB)

          1. 059
          1. 060
          2. 061
          1. 062
          2. 063
          1. 064
    1. 10/04/2018
      Call for Abstracts OASE #102 & OASE #103

      We invite you to read the Calls for Abstracts for OASE #102 and OASE #103.

      Read more

    2. 14/03/2018
      Presentation OASE #99

      An impression of the presentation of OASE #99 that took place on 1 Mach 2018 in Van Abbemuseum in Eindhoven, the Netherlands. In the pictures are the participants of the panel discussion that discussed “What future for the Architecture Museum?”: Triin Ojari, Sofie de Caigny, Mirko Zardini, Omer Kanipak and Bernard Colenbrander.

      Read more

    3. 16/02/2018
      INVITATION: symposium OASE #99

      What Future for the Architecture Museum?
      Thursday, 1 March 2018, from 17.00 - 19.30, Van Abbemuseum,
      Eindhoven (NL). More information and free registration via Evenbrite link!

      Read more

    4. 02/02/2018
      OASE #100 dedicated to OASE's graphic design, with indepth interview with Karel Martens

      In May OASE #100 about ‘The Architecture of the Journal’ will appear. Interesting public activities connected to this special edition of OASE are being planned, so keep an eye on this website.

      Read more

    5. 01/02/2018
      OASE #98 presented at the University of Greenwich, London
      1. Klaske Havik

      OASE #98 about Narrating Urban Landscapes was presented on 1 February 2018 at the University of Greenwich, London.
      Lectures by Bruno Notteboom, Kris Scheerlink and Klaske Havik. Image: Klaske Havik, editor of OASE, during the presentation.

      Read more

    6. 08/12/2017
      Now available: OASE #99. The Architecture Museum Effect

      Read more

    7. 10/11/2017
      Veronique Patteeuw talks to Rem Koolhaas

      Especially for the 25th anniversary of the Kunsthal in Rotterdam OASE editor Véronique Patteeuw, talked to architect Rem Koolhaas about the realisation, current function and the future of the building. Also OASE #94 about OMA was discussed!

      Read more

    8. 20/10/2017
      Workshop & Presentation OASE #98

      On 19 October 2017 OASE and the KU Leuven organised a workshop for students from KU Leuven and TU Delft. Later on OASE #98 was launched by the editors of this issue and the Scientific Board of OASE. Maarten Overdijk (Hogeschool voor de Kunsten Utrecht)  and Bas Smets (Bureau Bas Smets) gave lectures. 

      Read more

    9. 25/09/2017
      Launch OASE #98 Narrating Urban Landscapes

      The OASE Foundation cordially invites you to the presentation of OASE #98 on 19 October at the KU Leuven in Ghent, Belgium. 

      Read more

    10. 07/08/2017
      Lecture Veronique Patteeuw in New York

      On 18 July 2017 member of the OASE editorial staff Veronique Patteeuw discussed her work as co-editor of OASE #97 at the Columbia University Graduate School of Architecture, Planning and Preservation in New York. Click here for more details.

      Read more

    11. More news …