• 059
        • Faux Amis

        Abstract
        Irénée Scalbert analyses the position of the critic, elaborating the difficult relationship between the critic and the architect, against the background of the critical tradition in Great Britain. In the UK the position of the critic was unique, especially due to the works of critics like Reyner Banham, Colin Rowe in the 1960s and 1970s. Architecture criticism was understood as a form of intellectualism, sometimes opposing the practice of architecture, sometimes drawing a larger framework for practicing architects. The end of modernism, however, did not open the way for another approach in architecture, but for any other approach. This also has influenced criticism. According to Scalbert architecture criticism turned into a form of art criticism, emphasising complexity, uniqueness and craft. This perspective on differences has recently turned into the new object of criticism, as is the urgent and remaining issue of green architecture. But as Scalbert states in his essay: critics can only question these issues – answers have to be found in the practice of architecture.
          1. 059
          1. 060
          2. 061
          1. 062
          2. 063
          1. 064
        Citation
        Scalbert, I. (2010). Faux Amis. Constructing Criticism, OASE, (81), 59–64. Retrieved from https://www.oasejournal.nl/en/Issues/81/FauxAmis

        Download PDF (28.3 KB)

          1. 059
          1. 060
          2. 061
          1. 062
          2. 063
          1. 064
    1. 16/07/2020
      Now available: OASE #106 Table Settings. Reflections on architecture with Hannah Arendt

      > Positioning a new outlook on philosopher Hannah Arendt’s ideas, OASE #106 reveils how her writings very well can help us rethink architecture as a phenomenon and practice

      > Rethinking Hannah Arendt’s remarkably spatial view on ‘the world and its inhabitants’

      Read more

    2. 22/06/2020
      Call for Abstracts OASE #110

      A Project of the Soil
      Editors: David Peleman, Paola Viganò, Martina Barcelloni, Elsbeth Ronner

      Read more

    3. 28/04/2020
      Now available: OASE #105 Practices of Drawing

      > Insight into the work of both historical and contemporary architects
      > With a focus on beautiful architectural drawings over the past five centuries to grasp their role in design practice
      > With drawings by George Aitchison, Heinrich Tessenow, El Lissitzky, Lina Bo Bardi and Tony Fretton

      Read more

    4. 17/12/2019
      Call for Papers OASE #108

      OASE #108 More Than Meets the eye - Over- and underrated architecture

      Editors: David Peleman, Jantje Engels, Christophe Van Gerrewey

      “It is brilliant people say brilliant
      while it’s mere dilettantism
      What they touch becomes tasteless
      always the most obvious
      superficialities
      even the most exalted starts to stink”
      — Thomas Bernhard, Der Schein trügt, 1984

      Read more

    5. 21/11/2019
      Call for Abstracts OASE #107

      OASE #107 The drawing in landscape architecture and urbanism
      Editors: Bruno Notteboom, Frits Palmboom, Bart Decroos

      OASE invites everyone to read the Call for Abstracts for OASE #107.
      We are interested in two kinds of contributions that each start from the drawing:

      1. Textual contributions: historical or theoretical papers about a (series of) drawing(s).Proposals contain one image and an abstract of 300 words.
      2. Visual contributions: a specific (series of) drawing(s) from personal/actual practice.These proposals contain the drawing(s) themselves and a caption of a maximum of 300 words through which the proposal is situated within the theme of the issue.

      Proposals must be submitted via info@oasejournal.nl by 20 December 2019 and contain a title and CV (name, email address, affiliation and a bio of maximum 150 words). Proposals must be submitted in Dutch or English.

      Read the Call for detailed information.

      Read more

    6. 29/10/2019
      Presentation OASE #104

      On 25 November 2019 OASE #104 will be presented at the architecture school La Cambre in Brussel, Belgium.

      Read more

    7. 29/10/2019
      Now available: OASE #104 The Urban Household of Metabolism

      > Unique OASE issue on locations of metabolism that kept communities urban households in order.

      > With contributions by: Burkay Pasin & Gul Kacmaz Erk; Ben Vandenput; Koenraad Danneels; Julia von Mende; Dagmar Pelger & Emily Kelling; Ludo Groen; Nitin Bathla; Andrea Bortolotti, Andrea Aragone & Marco Ranzato; Diana Soeiro; Ciel Grommen, Dieter Leyssen & Maximiliaan Royakkers; Nadia Casabella & Jan Denoo; Riccardo M. Villa en Hans Vandermaelen.

      Read more

    8. 10/09/2019
      OASE #100 selected as one of The Best Dutch Book Designs 2018!

      Read more

    9. 12/06/2019
      Presentation OASE #103

      On 17 June 2019 OASE #103 will be presented at the University of Manchester. Starting at 12.30. Everyone is welcome and a lunch is provided. More information in the pdf. 

      Read more

    10. 23/05/2019
      Now available: OASE #103 Critical Regionalism Revisited

      > Internationally renowned architectural historian Kenneth Frampton received the Golden Lion at the Venice Biennale 2018. Critical Regionalism is his most known theory

      > Today, architects are searching for new ways to design and conceive built space. Critical Regionalism might just be the concept that we need to revisit.

      Read more

    11. More news …